Color Classics: Betty Boop in Poor Cinderella

I want to close out the string of Fleischer Color Classics cartons. There are a couple dozen more of them, but I think we’ve seen a fair sampling of what they’re like. For the last one, then, I’d like to go to the cartoon that inaugurated the series, Poor Cinderella, which as the title suggests, stars Betty Boop.

Of course it stars Betty Boop. When the Color Classics line of cartoons began, in 1934, the biggest stars Fleischer studios had were Betty Boop and Popeye and … well, actually, Popeye would probably be able to launch a line of musical cartoons on his own too. But Betty Boop was big. She still is; it’s still easy to find her licensed and marketed, which is all the more impressive when you consider there hasn’t been a new Betty Boop cartoon released since July of 1939. Let me put that in perspective: every single Tom and Jerry cartoon, and every Bugs Bunny cartoon, was made after Betty Boop was last in theaters (apart from cameo appearances as in Who Framed Roger Rabbit), and yet, she’s still at least recognizable.

(For my rhetorical purposes, yeah, I’m declaring A Wild Hare to be the first Bugs Bunny cartoon, but the precursors are hard to ignore.)

I honestly have no idea why Betty Boop wasn’t summoned for a series of cheaply-made cartoons in the 60s, at least, which seems like the natural era in which she might have got that degrading honor, or maybe in the early 80s as part of an attempt to show actual cartoons with female-type women as lead characters. A bunch of her cartoons were colorized, badly, in the 60s, at the same time a lot of the black-and-white Popeye cartoons were. This was done by South Korean animators hand-tracing and painting the frames, making the cartoons generally shoddier and more shady. Some madman then pulled out sequences to stitch together into a compilation cartoon titled Betty Boop For President, which can most properly be described as “Frankensteinian” and “dated and sexist in weird ways even for the 70s”. Wikipedia claims there was an attempt to make a new Betty Boop movie in the 90s that fell apart; I can accept that happening. I’m just surprised there hasn’t been more of that.

Poor Cinderella is Betty Boop’s only canonical appearance in color, although since at the time Disney had an exclusive license to use three-strip technicolor, Betty Boop’s cartoon was in two-strip Cinecolor. Cinecolor was built around red and cyan as the base colors. The color schemes to me look like vaguely reminiscent of old Christmas wrapping paper. It also gives the whole cartoon a faintly muted dreamlike attribute. I don’t think it’s just this cartoon; other Cinecolor films I’ve seen make a similar impression on me.

The cartoon — well, the story is exactly what the title implies. The Fleischers put in all their technical tricks to launch it well, though, with three-dimensional sets and lushly detailed animation, and didn’t forget the sorts of strange little comic asides that marked their most surreal work, even as the whole cartoon tries to be pretty sincerely direct and gentle.

The Prince is drawn in a rather realistic style, which never quite meshes with Betty Boop’s character design. That’s part of the price paid for trying to do a realistic-model cartoon with a character as stylized as Betty Boop at the core. The Fleischers had a similar problem with their first feature-length movie, Gulliver’s Travels, in which they needed characters ranging from rotoscoped-human-form (Gulliver, the Prince and Princess) through to very cartoonish (Gabby the Town Crier). Somehow Disney seems to have managed that blend more naturally in Snow White and the Seven Dwarves, although it might be that that movie is so much a part of everyone’s childhood they don’t even notice that, somehow, Snow White and Grumpy exist on-screen at the same time.

The title song isn’t going to haunt your mind the way Dancing On The Moon still does, but I enjoy it, and hope that you do also.


Author: Joseph Nebus

I was born 198 years to the day after Johnny Appleseed. The differences between us do not end there. He/him.

17 thoughts on “Color Classics: Betty Boop in Poor Cinderella”

  1. There was only one Betty Boop, and you deserve credit for doing your bit to help keep her legend alive.

    As someone who wasn’t born soon enough to have been the songwriter I fantasize being during that “Golden Age,” I also like to see credit given to composers and lyricists where due, In the case of POOR CINDERELLA, the honors go to Murray Mencher (aka Ted Murray) and Charles Tobias, who was one of the most prolific songwriters of the 1920s-30s (including the memorable DANCING ON THE MOON).


    1. I’m quite the fan of Betty Boop, and amazed my father because one of his sisters (whom we don’t see much anymore) was a much more severe super-fan. He didn’t see that coincidence coming.

      I did not think to look up the song composers and I should have. Thanks for the information about Murray and Tobias, especially the link to Dancing On The Moon.


    2. The Tobias brothers can be seen in this “Ive Got a Secret”
      In related cartoon news one of them apparently also wrote WB’s “The MerryGoRound Broke Down” along with more or less every other LooneyTune staple.


      1. Oh, wow, that’s neat and … wait, the I’ve Got A Secret contestant was the city clerk who issued Bess Myerson’s marriage license?  The heck is anyone supposed to guess that, even back then?


  2. If I’m not mistaken I believe Bill Menendez and the writers and animators of the Peanuts specials made a Betty Boop special for CBS, I’ve never seen it, but I think it had people behind it who respected the history of the character.


    1. Oh yes, I did run across mention of that after I’d gone through a series of Betty Boop firsts. If I’d known about it sooner and knew a YouTube or link for it I’d have done my best to review it. I should poke around some and see if it has got online somewhere. It should be a curiosity at least. And weirdly obscure for being so recent.


      1. Good news the Betty Boop special is on Youtube, It’s called “The Romance of Betty Boop”. Freddie returns as an ice man in love with Ms Boop, and has a nice sight gag as a block of ice melts to a cube as he walks up to BB’s top floor apartment. Also a blink and you’ll miss it gag — in an establishing shot a grocer washes a window that says Shultz’s, I assume a shout out to their usual boss. To wrap up I didn’t think it was as bad as it could have been, nor as good as it should have been. But at least it exists.


        1. I am glad to hear this, that it’s available and that it isn’t as bad as could have been, at least. I did get, from one of those dollar bins as we had in the 90s, a DVD recording of the Betty Boop for President “movie” stitched together from colorized cartoons and wow is that bad.


Please Write Something Funnier Than I Thought To

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: