Paramount Cartoon Studios, formerly Famous Studios, formerly formerly Fleischer Cartoons, was one of the two most prolific makes of the 1960s Popeye shorts. As their corporate history indicates, they had nearly three decades of experience making Popeye cartoons before getting their slice of the King Features contract. So, I notice, a lot of my reviews express similar sentiments. Paramount was by this time very good at making a cartoon that parsed. The stories almost all had clear plots, and straightforward narratives. The animation might rarely be very good, or even lively, but it would never be bad. This was always the quietly competent studio, not worried that they never hit a home run because they can get on base any time they want.
So a lot of these cartoons feel very routine; you’ll see how many of them I describe as Popeye and Brutus compete for a job, or soem similar stock premise. They sometimes break through, though, particularly when they try for a heavy plot. The best is likely Mystery Melody, adapted from the comic strip. But there’s a version of the search for Poopdeck Pappy here, also interesting; or a five-minute Gulliver’s Travels, or Popeye saving Goon Island. Most any time they try for a more complex narrative it works, and gives us a good interesting story.
In going over the list I find there weren’t any cartoons that I skipped for being too racist. (There is one that wasn’t put on King Features’s YouTube channel and it might have been for a troublesome character depiction, though.) That stands out; there’ve been a number of cartoons I noped out of, mostly for poorly-considered depictions of Native Americans, sometimes for depictions of, say, Chinese people. I’m not sure how Paramount Cartoon Studios avoided that. It’s easy to say their long experience working under the Hays Code trained them to avoid ethnic stereotyping except they did theatrical cartoons with “Indian princessess” and other motifs that these days get a disclaimer.
In any event. If one of these cartoons comes up and you see Seymour Kneitel’s name all over it? You’re in for a safe enough watch. Might not be the great cartoon you’re hoping for, but it’s not going to leave you wondering what the heck that was all about.
Here, with a list order taken from whatever made sense to the Popeye Wikia, is the list of Paramont-made cartoons and what I thought of them.
- Hits and Missiles – one that I did back in 2014 and didn’t revisit for this sequence. I need to replace the video, though.
- The Ghost Host – not enough ghost shenanigans.
- Strikes, Spares an’ Spinach – A bowling cartoon! You never see Popeye go bowling.
- Jeep Is Jeep – another chance to meet Eugene the Jeep for the first time!
- The Spinach Scholar – Popeye goes back to school and gets mostly shamed for his trouble.
- Psychiatricks – It looks like a clip show, but isn’t!
- Rags to Riches to Rags – King Features has withdrawn the video for some reason. Features a P G Wodehouse reference.
- Hair Cut-Ups – Another withdrawn video, this one where Popeye tells the story of Samson and Delilah to encourage Swee’Pea to get a haircut. Features Brutus not being the antagonist.
- Poppa Popeye – Swee’Pea gets swiped by a fake father, and Popeye loses it entirely.
- Quick Change Olie – The Whiffle Bird sends Popeye and Wimpy back to Ye Olden Days.
- The Valley of the Goons – Popeye’s shanghaied into a Goon-hunting expedition and fights for their liberation instead.
- Me Quest for Poopdeck Pappy – Another take on what must be Popeye’s most-retold story; features comparisons, of course to Goonland and to Popeye’s Pappy.
- Moby Hick – The Sea Hag tricks Popeye into helping her recover proceeds from a backstory crime!
- Mirror Magic – Popeye’s Mother in one of her very few animated appearances!
- It Only Hurts When They Laughs – Not reviewed and I don’t see any mention of why I skipped it.
- Wimpy the Moocher – Not reviewed and I don’t see any mention of why I skipped it. The Popeye Wikia’s article mentions how this is mostly a Wimpy-versus-Geezil cartoon, though, and Geezil is so heavily ethnically coded I imagine without knowing that King features maybe didn’t want to show anything where he was a load-bearing character.
- Voo-Doo to You Too – another withdrawn video, this one where the Sea Hag makes a voodoo doll of Popeye. I imagine without knowing that the casual depiction of voodoo might be why the video was withdrawn but can’t say.
- Popeye Goes Sale-ing – another withdrawn video, of Olive Oyl and Popeye doing department store gags.
- Popeye’s Travels – yet another withdrawn video, somehow, but you get the part anyone remembers about Gulliver’s Travels wrapped up in five and a half minutes.
- Incident at Missile City – one I’ve looked at twice now, with a strange world of missile-people, plus Popeye.
- Dog Catcher Popeye – Popeye saves a dog from the catcher, that’s all.
- What’s News – one more withdrawn video, for a cartoon adapted from the comic strip where Popeye takes over a newspaper.
- Spinach Greetings – the Sea Hag has captured Santa Claus and only Popeye can save him!
- The Baby Contest – Swee’Pea and Brutus’s son compete for a baby contest, eventually.
- Oil’s Well That Ends Well – Olive Oyl buys a worthless oil well from Brutus that, whoops, turns out to be a gusher.
- Motor Knocks – Yup, another withdrawn video. But it’s the rare short where Popeye starts out being attentive to his girlfriend.
- Amusement Park – Swee’Pea gets roped into the freak show somehow.
- Duel to the Finish – Olive Oyl tries to make Popeye jealous, so she woos Wimpy because, I mean, have you seen her other choices? And Wimpy beats Popeye in a duel!
- Gem Jam – Sea Hag hypnotizes Olive Oyl to steal a cursed gem. This one is set in India and avoids having offensive depictions of Indian people by not having depictions of anyone besides Popeye, Olive Oyl, and the Sea Hag.
- The Bathing Beasts – Popeye and Brutus compete for the Mister America title.
- The Rain Breaker – Popeye goes up to the clouds to work out why the weather forecast is wrong.
- Messin’ Up the Mississippi – For some reason it’s set on a river showboat.
- Love Birds – Olive Oyl’s pet love bird needs a girlfriend, so Popeye goes to a pet shop run by a monkey.
- Sea Serpent – a withdrawn video, because it shows the shocking truth about the Loch Ness Monster.
- Boardering on Trouble – Popeye and Brutus fight over … the management of their Old Western hotel? Also Popeye draws a gun on Brutus for some reason?
- Aladdin’s Lamp – Olive Oyl accidentally buys a genie lamp and the Sea Hag wants it.
- Butler Up – Once again a withdrawn video. Popeye pretends to be Olive’s butler so she can impress Brutus.
- The Leprechaun – There’s a whole bunch of leprechauns in this, and Popeye gets honorary leprechaun status, which is nice for him, I suppose.
- County Fair – Popeye and Brutus compete to win the county fair.
- Hamburgers Aweigh – another withdrawn video. Popeye uses the Whiffle Hen to turn Wimpy into a burger-hater and the Sea Hag gets in on the mind-control game.
- Popeye’s Double Trouble – yet another withdrawn video. Sea Hag tries to pass her bad-luck coin off on Popeye but, what do you know, but she has the bad luck to slip him her good-luck coin instead. Also, Sea Hag impersonates Olive Oyl and Popeye doesn’t catch on.
- Kiddie Kapers – With a dose of Fountain of Youth potion Brutus turns handsome. With some more, Popeye and Olive Oyl turn into kids.
- The Mark of Zero – Telling the story of Popeye as the people’s hero, Zero, to Olive’s niece Deezil Oyl.
- Myskery Melody – A good moody piece, adapted from the comic strip, revealing the Sea Hag and Poopdeck Pappy’s past.
- Scairdy Cat – Brutus turns to chemical warfare, deploying Fear Gas against Popeye, a thing that won’t ever backfire.
- Operation Ice-Tickle – Popeye and Brutus compete to bring back the North Pole and win a date with Olive Oyl! Not the first time I’ve shown a cartoon featuring a balloon flight to the North Pole, somehow!
- The Cure – Wimpy signs up for Hamburgers Anonymous, to overcome his shame at swiping a quarter off of Popeye, and Sea Hug works to bust him out of there.
- William Won’t Tell – A remix of the William tell story. Features Shaggy in a bit part, wearing Olive Oyl’s outfit and Brutus’s beard!
- Pop Goes the Whistle – Swee’pea goes in search of his lost teddy bear and Popeye almost kills himself trying to catch him.
- Autographically Yours – Not reviewed and I don’t know why; I don’t think they posted it.
- A Poil for Olive Oyl – Popeye figures to dive for pearls himself rather than pay for someone who’s already done the work.
- My Fair Olive – Popeye and Brutus compete for Olive Oyl’s affection by … jousting? For some reason?
- Giddy Gold – The Whiffle Bird turns the contents of a Tunnel of Love ride into real things! Oh, Tunnel of Love rides often depict monsters, that’s right. Well, I’m sure it’ll all work out great.s
- Strange Things Are Happening – Everybody is being all weird around Popeye and why are they all talking like they’re trying to kidnap him?
- The Medicine Man – Popeye and Olive Oyl are selling patent medicine and somehow Brutus, the town’s doctor, is the bad guy?
- A Mite of Trouble – once more a withdrawn video. Sea Hag sneaks a fake Swee’Pea into Popeye’s house to find a treasure map.
- Who’s Kiddin’ Zoo – Popeye and Brutus compete to be the new assistant zookeeper, Finally, some kangaroo content!
- Robot Popeye – another withdrawn video, this one where Brutus gets to build the robot Popeye.
- Sneaking Peeking – Popeye tells a fairy tale about the Happy Princess opening a box that contains Mister Mischief.
- Seer-Ring Is Believer-Ring – Olive Oyl accidentally gets a magic ring so Evil-Eye hypnotizes her to get it back. Also somehow Wimpy declares he’s treating everyone at Rough House’s Diner.
- The Wiffle Bird’s Revenge – Her revenge is turning Wimpy into a werewolf for some reason. Also, we get to see Rough House!
- Going… Boing.. Gone – It’s Wimpy and Brutus struggling against each other, with Popeye just included because it’s his name on the series. Features some vanishing cream, a carton motif we don’t get enough of anymore.
- Popeye Thumb – What if Popeye but small? And this teaches Swee’Pea to play baseball.
2 thoughts on “What I Thought About All The Paramount Popeye Cartoons”
Many of those “withdrawn” cartoons can be found on the Popeye Official You Tube page run by King Features. I wish Paramount had done the 101 rather than Jack Kinney. However, they probably took what they could handle at the time. They were still producing cartoons for theatres. Wimpy the Moocher and It Only Hurts When They Laugh were based upon Sunday pages. I didn’t mind the stock ending of Popeye singing because it was nicely inserted and became a tradition. Even, at 5, I could tell the difference between a Paramount cartoon and a Jack Kinney one. Although it wouldn’t be until I was 14 how much of a difference.
I have spotted many of them. I keep thinking to spend an afternoon going through the withdrawn cartoons and matching them up to the individual videos, but it’s so hard setting the time aside for that. On the other hand I’d find it so soothing, too, to do. I don’t know.
It’s a good question why Paramount managed so much better than Kinney at producing such a great number of cartoons. I’d always chalked it up to the institution having 25-plus years of experience drawing Popeye, so that they could turn out some more without any strain. That they were so established an organization, compared to all the other studios that were (as best I can tell) a couple years old at most has to have mattered some too.
Now at age five, I don’t think I could tell the difference between Kinney (or the other studios) and Paramount. I could tell the King Features cartoons from the theatricals, easily, and knew that I was more likely going to see fun characters like Eugene the Jeep in the King Features. It didn’t make up for the worse animation, but I’ll watch anything with the Sea Hag and Eugene in it.
I appreciate the tip about shorts being based on Sunday pages. I’d known about a couple shorts adapted from daily strip stories but never thought about the Sundays as source material, even though a lot of them would be well-fitted for adaptation.